How Agropur Uses Government to Limit Competition

Say goodbye to free markets and your competition

Written by Van Hamilton Barbeau

Published September 29, 2026 · Read time: 4 minutes 51 seconds

I come from a Québon family.

Like many people in Québec City, I drink my Québon chocolate milk by the gallon and pour Québon 35% cream on my Jos Louis, bûches de Noël, birthday cakes, and literally any dessert.

My beloved Québon products are made by Agropur, a dairy cooperative based in Longueuil.

Rather than solely relying on the usual firm-specific competitive advantages, Agropur relies heavily on another kind of advantage.

Government.

I'm a staunch advocate of free markets and limiting government intervention in business, so if you bristled just reading the word government, don't get your knickers in a knot.

There are very specific instances where government intervention is needed.

Food production is one of these instances.

Because it operates in an industry the government shields from competition, Agropur has earned returns that would be competed away in a free market.

Here's how the government limited Agropur’s competition, and how you can spot the industries where government protection is an option.

The Competitive Advantage

Government

Usually we focus on competitive advantages a company develops internally.

But sometimes the advantage comes from an external source.

And sometimes that source is a group of people we all love to hate.

No, not people who clap when the plane lands.

The other group we all love to hate.

Politicians.

A government advantage is an externally created advantage that usually comes in the form of quotas, regulation, subsidies, and everyone's favorite word since April 2nd, 2025: tariffs.

The goal is to give companies an economic advantage or protection from competitors.

For decades, Agropur has benefitted from government intervention in the form of supply management, along with import limits and tariffs.

This government intervention has allowed Agropur to generate returns that would be competed away in a free market.

How The Government Built It

1. Limit Milk Supply

I once had an all-around horrible experience at the Club Med[i] in Charlevoix.

They topped it off by claiming we couldn't order cheese fondue because Charlevoix, a region known for cheese, had run out of its entire supply of cheese.

This was obviously a bold-faced lie, and lying about cheese is about as heinous as it gets.

While Club Med lied about Charlevoix’s cheese supply, the Canadian government does actually limit the supply of raw milk.

Dairy farmers supply raw milk to dairy processing companies like Agropur[ii] who make dairy products like cheese and yogurt.

In a free market, farmers could produce as much milk as they want.

But in Canada, the government caps how much they can collectively produce, which keeps any large new player from entering the market and competing with Agropur.

New entrants can’t enter the market because farmers aren't allowed to produce above the government mandated limit to meet any large entrant’s massive milk needs.

Competitors can only enter at a small scale that fits under the government's annual production limits.

By limiting how much milk farmers can produce, the government makes it such that there is only enough milk to supply three large dairy processors: Agropur, Saputo, and Lactalis.

In setting supply limits, the government therefore protects Agropur from domestic competitors.

2. Limit Dairy Products Coming Into Canada

The government didn't stop at domestic competition.

It also shielded Agropur from foreign competition.

Canada sets quotas for how much foreign dairy can be imported.

Once those quotas are filled, any additional imports get hit with hefty tariffs.

We’re talking 241% for milk, 245.5% for cheese, and 298.5% for butter.

To quote Trump, those are very "bigly" numbers.[iii]

At tariffs that exorbitant, foreign producers simply stop exporting to Canada once the quota is filled.

So Agropur doesn't have to worry much about foreign competitors.

With fewer competitors, Agropur earns returns it wouldn't enjoy in a free market where the finest cheeses from France and Italy could flood the market.

Why the Moat Is Stable

Until a little over a year ago, if you had asked me how stable this moat was, I would have said it was shrinking.

For years, each new trade deal raised the quotas for foreign dairy entering Canada, therefore chipping away at the limited competition Agropur benefitted from.

But in the past year, the world has shifted, with import restrictions and tariffs multiplying around the world.

So Agropur's moat, and its comfortable shortage of competitors, looks stable.

At this point you might be thinking, "Hey Van, this whole no competition thing sounds great. How do I get in on this? I hate competing. It’s so tiring.”

If that's you, there are ways to identify industries most likely to enjoy this kind of government intervention that limits competition.

To borrow from Alexander Hamilton's Report on the Subject of Manufactures, governments should and tend to intervene when an industry is:

  • Important to national security or self-sufficiency - Defense is the obvious one, but dairy fits too, because depending on another country for your food supply is dangerous[iv]
  • Nascent - Industries a country is trying to get off the ground, like EVs

The world order is clearly changing

Tariffs and import restrictions are now levied on seemingly anything, so the future might bring less competition even in industries that should have competition.

But if we assume we go back to the rules of commerce as they’ve historically worked, you may be able to benefit from limited competition in the industry types listed above.

Québec City: September 29, 2026

[i] Somebody honestly tell the Ministère de la Langue française that there’s barely any French going on in that place. It's embarrassing. [ii] Agropur is also a milk producer (a dairy farmer, the kind of entity that supplies raw milk to processors), but we'll focus on its role as a dairy processing company to illustrate the mechanics of the industry. [iii] I know there's debate about whether he says "bigly" or "big league." I honestly hear "bigly." [iv] For anybody thinking it's not fair that Agropur doesn't have to compete: sure, it's not "fair," but it beats depending on China or Russia or anyone else for all our dairy. What if that country decides it doesn't like us anymore and stops exporting, and we don't have enough of our own producers left? Doesn't seem so crazy given the current state of the world, right?
Source: Agropur, Canada Border Services Agency, Credit Suisse, Morgan Stanley, Report on the Subject of Manufactures.

Legal Information and Disclosures

This memorandum expresses the views of the author as of the date indicated and such views are subject to change without notice. Les Douves Inc. (Les Douves) and Louveteau Global Inc. (Louveteau Global) have no duty or obligation to update the information contained herein. Further, Les Douves and Louveteau Global make no representation, and it should not be assumed, that past investment performance is an indication of future results. Moreover, wherever there is the potential for profit there is also the possibility of loss.

This memorandum is being made available for educational purposes only and should not be used for any other purpose. The information contained herein does not constitute and should not be construed as an offering of advisory services or an offer to sell or solicitation to buy any securities or related financial instruments in any jurisdiction. Certain information contained herein concerning economic trends and performance is based on or derived from information provided by independent third-party sources. Les Douves and Louveteau Global believe that the sources from which such information has been obtained are reliable; however, they cannot guarantee the accuracy of such information and have not independently verified the accuracy or completeness of such information or the assumptions on which such information is based.

This memorandum, including the information contained herein, may not be copied, reproduced, republished, or posted in whole or in part, in any form without the prior written consent of Les Douves and Louveteau Global.

© 2026 Les Douves Inc.

Other Memos

The competitive advantages of Québec’s best companies

The Les Douves Newsletter

Join the operators, executives, and investors receiving sharp analysis on Québec’s best companies every week